• 0 Posts
  • 3 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: December 23rd, 2023

help-circle

  • IMO it comes down to the actual clients and work. Like you said, there are legit reasons for digital forensics.

    I assume in your country that there is some judicial process, including challenges and appeals, involved in searches and that those phones are allegedly being used in specific, articulated crimes. If that is the case then I think there’s justification for trying to get into the phone. However if that judicial process is absent or a sham, there are no crimes being articulated beyond hand-waving like “terrorism” or “national security”, or the entire apparatus is rotten to the core, then it becomes immoral.

    I know people who have had similar jobs and when a bad job comes down they refuse. So far, they haven’t been fired, but they were willing to be fired. If you were cracking the phones of child molesters and human traffickers then you’re doing good work. If it’s people protesting climate change you’d have an ethical duty to refuse, and be prepared to walk.